Gmail's Blue Checkmark and Question Mark: What They Prove
A blue checkmark in Gmail, a question mark beside a sender, an "unverified" label in Outlook — each answers a narrow technical question, and none answers the one you are actually asking. What each checks, in Google's and Microsoft's own words.
Short answer
Gmail's blue checkmark means the sender has verified that they own the email address and the brand logo, which Google checks using BIMI, a Verified Mark Certificate and DMARC. It confirms who sent the message — not that the message is safe or that what it asks of you is genuine.
Jump to your problem 7
- Gmail's question mark: the message is not authenticated
- How to check authentication yourself
- Gmail's blue checkmark: the sender owns the address and the logo
- What the checkmark does not prove
- Outlook's question mark and "unverified" sender
- The change is the signal, not the symbol
- What to do with a message you are unsure about
Gmail and Outlook both put small marks beside a sender's name, and both are widely read as a verdict on whether an email is safe. Neither is. Each one answers a narrow technical question about where the message came from, and the gap between that question and "is this email real" is where most of the confusion lives.
Here is what each mark actually claims, taken from Google's and Microsoft's own documentation.
Gmail's question mark: the message is not authenticated
Google's wording is specific: if you see a question mark next to the sender's name, the message is not authenticated, and that means Gmail does not know whether the message is coming from the person who appears to be sending it. Google's advice is to be careful about replying or downloading attachments.
What it is not is an accusation. Google says so directly on the same page, and this is the part that gets left out everywhere else:
Messages that aren't authenticated aren't necessarily spam. Sometimes authentication doesn't work for real organizations who send mail to big groups, like messages sent to mailing lists.
A mailing list that rewrites a message as it passes it on can break the sender's signature without anybody doing anything wrong. So a question mark on a newsletter you subscribed to years ago is ordinary. A question mark on a message claiming to be from your bank is not.
How to check authentication yourself
You do not have to rely on the symbol. Google gives the steps for reading the result directly.
In Gmail on a computer: open the email and click the down arrow below the sender's name. The message is authenticated if you see a Mailed by header with the domain name, and a Signed by header with the sending domain.
In another mail client, such as Outlook or Apple Mail: open the message headers and find the Authentication-Results header. If the message was authenticated by SPF or DKIM you will see spf=pass or dkim=pass.
If reading raw headers is more than you want to do, our email header analyzer does the same reading and shows the result in plain words.
Gmail's blue checkmark: the sender owns the address and the logo
The blue checkmark is a different and stronger signal, but still a narrow one. Google says it means the sender has verified that they own the email address and brand logo. Three things sit behind it:
- BIMI, the standard that lets a sender attach their brand logo to email.
- VMC, a certificate issued by a certificate authority that verifies the sender owns that logo.
- DMARC, which helps mail systems separate real messages from spoofed ones.
Google adds that verified emails still go through Gmail's normal anti-abuse checks, and the logo is shown only if they pass. Hovering over the checkmark shows information about the sender's domain.
So the checkmark is a real statement about identity: this message came from the domain it claims, and that domain is entitled to show that logo. Getting one requires a certificate and a published DMARC policy, which is more than a casual scammer will do.
What the checkmark does not prove
It does not say the message is safe, that the offer in it is real, or that the company behind it is trustworthy. It says the sender is who the domain says they are.
Google makes the underlying point about authentication plainly in its own guidance for senders:
Because spammers can also authenticate mail, authentication by itself isn't enough to guarantee your messages can be delivered.
Spammers can and do pass SPF and DKIM — on domains they genuinely control. Authentication proves the envelope, not the contents. A message can be perfectly authenticated, carry a checkmark, and still be a scam run from a domain the scammer registered and configured properly.
The practical consequence: a checkmark is a reason not to worry about spoofing. It is not a reason to trust a link, a payment request, or an attachment.
Outlook's question mark and "unverified" sender
Outlook does the same job with different words. Microsoft's current guidance says Outlook verifies that the sender is who they say they are and marks malicious messages as junk, and then:
If the message is suspicious but isn't deemed malicious, the sender will be marked as unverified to notify the receiver that the sender may not be who they appear to be.
An older Microsoft post, now in its archived blogs, describes the symbol itself: when Outlook.com or Office 365 cannot verify the sender's identity using SPF, DKIM or any other technique, it displays a ? in the sender photo. The criterion it gives is that the message must pass either SPF or DKIM.
That post also makes the most useful point anyone has made about these symbols. It says plainly that not every message failing authentication is malicious; that you should be careful with unauthenticated mail from a sender you do not recognise; and — the part worth keeping — that a sender who normally carries no question mark and suddenly does .
It is archived rather than current documentation, so treat the detail about the sender photo as a description of how the feature was introduced rather than a promise about today's interface. The principle in it has not changed, and Microsoft's current page says the same thing in different words.
The change is the signal, not the symbol
This is the part worth remembering, and it is Microsoft's point generalised.
A question mark on a mailing list is noise. A question mark on a sender who has never had one is information. The symbol on its own tells you about one message in isolation; the change tells you something about a sender you already know.
So the useful habit is not "look for the checkmark". It is noticing when a sender who normally looks one way suddenly looks another — and then checking the address itself rather than the symbol.
What to do with a message you are unsure about
- Read the actual sending address, not the display name. Display names are free text and can say anything.
- Check the domain against what the company publishes. Our official sender directory lists the addresses and domains major brands say they send from.
- Do not use the link in the email to check whether the email is true. Open the company's site or app yourself and look there.
The longer version of all three, with the provider-by-provider steps, is in how to check if an email is real. If you have already clicked something, go straight to what to do after clicking a phishing link.
How this guide was checked · November 2026
Verified against 4 official sources
Every step, setting and limit in this guide was checked against the provider’s own documentation on support.google.com, support.microsoft.com and learn.microsoft.com. Anything we couldn’t confirm was left out.
- 01 Google: Check if your Gmail message is authenticated support.google.com
- 02 Google: Learn about verified emails (the blue checkmark, BIMI, VMC and DMARC) support.google.com
- 03 Microsoft: Phishing and suspicious behavior in Outlook support.microsoft.com
- 04 Microsoft (archived blog): Showing a question mark '?' in the sender photo when a message is not authenticated learn.microsoft.com
Questions
Frequently asked questions
What does the blue checkmark in Gmail mean?
Gmail's blue checkmark means the sender has verified that they own the email address and the brand logo, which Google checks using BIMI, a Verified Mark Certificate and DMARC. It confirms who sent the message — not that the message is safe or that what it asks of you is genuine.
What does a question mark next to a sender in Gmail mean?
The message is not authenticated, which Google explains as Gmail not knowing whether it came from the person who appears to be sending it. Google also says unauthenticated messages are not necessarily spam — authentication often fails for mailing lists.
Can a scam email have a blue checkmark?
A scammer who registers a domain and sets it up properly can pass authentication on that domain. Google notes that spammers can also authenticate mail, so a verified sender badge rules out spoofing of someone else's domain, not a scam run from the sender's own.
What does "unverified" mean in Outlook?
Microsoft says that when a message is suspicious but not judged malicious, the sender is marked unverified to tell you the sender may not be who they appear to be. An archived Microsoft post describes this as a question mark shown in the sender photo when SPF and DKIM cannot confirm the sender.
How do I check whether an email is authenticated myself?
In Gmail on a computer, open the message and click the down arrow under the sender's name: an authenticated message shows a Mailed by header with the domain and a Signed by header. In other mail apps, look for Authentication-Results in the headers and check for spf=pass or dkim=pass.
Should I delete every email with a question mark on it?
No. Newsletters and mailing lists often fail authentication for ordinary reasons. The useful signal is a change: a sender who never had a question mark and suddenly does may be being spoofed, which is Microsoft's own advice.
Related guides
Keep reading
Spectrum Email Security
Spectrum Email Security: Spam, Phishing and Fake Charter Emails
How Spectrum's spam filtering works, where to report an email pretending to be Charter, and the steps Spectrum gives if you have already replied to one.
5 min read
AT&T Mail Security
AT&T Email Security: Secure Mail Keys and Account Protection
What a secure mail key really gives away, the account protections AT&T actually offers, and why sbcglobal.net and bellsouth.net addresses attract more fake support than most.
6 min read
Xfinity Email (Comcast) Security
Xfinity Email Security: Two-Step Verification and Account Protection
Turn on two-step verification for your Xfinity ID, understand what third-party email access gives away, and know which Xfinity messages are real — from Xfinity's own security pages.
5 min read
Yandex Mail Security
Yandex Mail Security: Yandex Key, App Passwords and Sessions
Protect your Yandex Mail with two-factor authentication, app passwords for email programs, a recovery phone and the log-out-everywhere switch.
3 min read
Mailfence Security
Mailfence Security: 2FA, Service Passwords and Connection History
Lock down a Mailfence account with two-factor authentication and backup codes, service-specific passwords for email programs, and the connections history log.
3 min read
Mail.com Security
mail.com Security: Two-Factor Authentication and a Hacked Account
Set up two-factor authentication on mail.com, keep your secret key safe, and work through mail.com’s steps if your account was hacked.
3 min read